why do people say this?

[wolfsoul]

I am also quite offended that I'm considered stupid for going to a reputable breeder rather than a shelter. I have my own personal problems that are my reasoning for this, however I don't see that it should matter. I'm still going to adopt a cat, and I'm still going to adopt rats, and probably other rodents. Heck, I'm even going to have my own rescue or shelter, plus maybe I'll foster animals while I'm at it. It isn't to 'make up' for not getting my dogs from shelters, it's because I truly love animals and want to help them. Going to a good breeder doesn't mean you are stupid -- it could possibly mean that you've done your research and you know how to keep away from a bad breeder.

[2kitties]

I don't think there is anything wrong with responsible breeders who are working to keep and better their breeds through proper breeding, homing, and educating. I do have a problem with puppy mills, backyard breeders and people who just think they want their dog to have puppies or their kids to see puppies be born or they want to make a few bucks or whatever. These are the kinds of people that give breeding a bad name. They dont' take into account the hereditary issues of particular breeds, they will breed to close too the bloodline and they don't properly screen new homes.

[pitbullmommy]

Originally posted by moosmom
Because they are STUPID and having nothing else to do with their money except line the pockets of the breeders instead of offering a home to a pet that is on death row.

Makes me sick!!!

That offended me also and i think it was disrespectful to say something like that when there are so many peopl on this chat that have pure breeds. I dont think it was right to say, I think every her has a love for animals and would never want to see bad things happen but no one should pass judgement on anyone bc of where we got out dogs! I just think that statement was rude and uncalled for. sorry my opinion.

[mugsy]

I personally feel that if we put a 5 year moratorium on ALL breeding that we wouldn't have the problem we have now. It would force people to get their dogs from a rescue or shelter. I would LOVE to put the shelter employees out of a job.

I will NEVER get a dog from anywhere except a shelter, but, I'm not everyone and people will get their pets from where they so choose. My only wish is that people would consider a shelter dog before going to a breeder....now....understand that I realize that many won't do that because they have something specific in mind, but, they are out there if you look hard enough.

Sorry if I offend anyone, but, I vote for shelter dogs....they need a home more than a breeder's pup...just my opinion...take it for what it's worth (which isn't much! lol )

[Kfamr]

Originally posted by moosmom
Sorry, but there are PLENTY of purebreed rescue organizations out there to adopt from, rather than lining the pocket of a breeder.

Secondly, I never once directed my opinions at anyone in particular. They are MY opinions and I am sticking to them. It's YOUR problem if you are offended by them.

I'd never even think of buying from a breeder and that comment offended me. You called alot of the dog owners on Pet Talk stupid. Which it wasn't directly towards them, but there are many who have bought from breeder on this site, and maybe you should think before you type next time.

And then, coming back with an "WHATEVER" after many stated that they were offended wasn't too great either.

But, that's just my opinion.

[Kfamr]

I agree with you 100% Molly.

And your opinion is worth some.... maybe just a little.

[popcornbird]

While rescuing is a wonderful thing and should be encouraged, I don't believe anyone should *condemn* people for getting animals from reputable breeders. Everyone has their reasons. Getting a pet is making a life commitment, and people make their decisions based on different reasons. Calling them stupid is uncalled for. There are other ways of stating the same opinion...........stating things angrily will only make people run from you. Just my honest opinion.

[wolfsoul]

Originally posted by mugsy
I personally feel that if we put a 5 year moratorium on ALL breeding that we wouldn't have the problem we have now.

While I agree completely with what you're saying, I do think that 5 years is an awful long time, because then after five years when people start breeding again, all of the female dogs will be 5 years older. It's healthy to start them off at a younger age. I think they should just make backyard breeding illegal, and most of our problems would end. Researchers have found out that 65% of the dog population comes from backyard breeders.

[PJ's Mom]

Originally posted by moosmom
They are MY opinions and I am sticking to them. It's YOUR problem if you are offended by them.

Fine. It's your problem that you can't voice your opinions without offending...knowing full well that a lot of people here got their pets from breeders. A little tact wouldn't kill you.

[mugsy]

Originally posted by wolfsoul
. Researchers have found out that 65% of the dog population comes from backyard breeders.

I would have guessed higher, but, that's still a lot. Actually what needs to happen is that the law enforcement and legislators have to get their heads out and realize that there is a problem and the AKC needs to stop giving licenses to anyone who sends something in and start inspecting like they are supposed to do. As always, it's bureacracy to get something done, but, like always, it probably never will.

[GoldenRetrLuver]

Originally posted by PJ's Mom
Fine. It's your problem that you can't voice your opinions without offending...knowing full well that a lot of people here got their pets from breeders. A little tact wouldn't kill you.

Agreed 100%.

[tikeyas_mom]

I will be getting my next dog from a breeder that spends all their money and time in bettering the breed, I have gotten Tikeya and oscar both from bad breeders, but I didnt know the difference, i was ignorant. But i wouldent for one second change a thing if i could.

[primabella]

I was very offended by certain statements in here. Mickey is my baby and my dog. The dog I have been waiting for since I ever wanted a dog. And he is from a breeder. Does that make him any lesser or any better than a shelter dog? I think not. Although I totally support rescue and shelters and admire anyone who does rescue, I did not rescue a dog. Because I wanted a certain breed of dog that would be good for my family. All dogs in the shelters (when we looked) were large and we don't have the yard or size of house to accomodate to a large breed dog. Why rescue a dog and give him a miserable life in a small house with little room to play? I don't see the fairness in that.

After searching every shelter in the area we turned to a breeder and that's it. Maybe I should have waited longer and gone back to the shelters, looking for a Sheltie or Sheltie mix...but I didn't. Do I regret it? Not at all. It's just the way things worked out for me.

I will definitely try and rescue in the future. I want to. Adoption or buying a dog is up to that person. Sure adoption is an amazing thing, but it should never feel like it's being pressured.

[Amber]

Man o man....

why did you all make this thread about your dogs from breeders? Mooshoo was just speaking her mind. All I asked was why someone would say that and promise themselves that they would get their pet from a shelter, but ends up getting from a breeder.

So WHY? Like I said this is somthing that is going on right now, with me personally. Nothing to do with your dogs/cats.

And im sorry if it was offended. but thats life.

this has nothing to do with you and your dogs, and why you got them.

[Miss Meow]

Amber, to try to answer your original question, people might change their minds because: they're hypocrites and try to 'do the right thing' but had no intention in the first place; they might be talked into buying the current trendy dog that hasn't made its way to shelters yet (eg Staffies are huge here right now, and will no doubt be filling the shelters later in the year ); or they might not find the right dog on a shelter visit and genuinely change their minds.

[edited to delete stuff about my dogs that Amber doesn't want ]