I don't claim to understand men and I am 49,was married for 17 years to the love of my life when he left me for an old college girlfriend.
I agree with the others comments. I would move on. I hate to say this but it sounds to me like he is interested in someone else or why would he feel awkward about talking to you or looking at you. He is feeling guilty about something. Also, I find it hard to believe at 18 that you were his first girlfriend ever.
At least you are young. I am old and trying to meet someone. It is a lot harder at my age.
Hang in there.
Bookmarks