Debbie I'm sooo sorry your precious Tubby is gone. It's never easy saying goodbye, but he did have many, many happy years with you, but it's still such a short time I'm sure. I've lost too many before their time, and many as elderly kitties in failing health, but it always is heartbreaking losing our beloved babies. I was so happy to hear, and see the pictures of Tubby feeling and looking good, but only God knows when it's time to call our kitty angels home. RIP sweet beloved Tubby, and Hugs Debbie for loving him so.