I would squish them all once and come back for a second round. My husband won't allow us to have a kitty so I make do with squishing the ferrets. Sebastian likes it and will give me a little kiss, Miko just wants to run and wiggles like he's being killed. Sasha the border collie x loves me to squish her. If I had a favorite I would have to say Glacier's Boots - he's just so cool.