Scat mats for dogs?

[.sarah]

Nova is getting really bad at jumping on the counters lately. Last night I was baking cookies and dog treats. I went to the bathroom to come back to one less Snickerdoodle Then, later on, I heard her jumping on the counter from the living room. I called her and could tell there was something in her mouth so I told her to drop it (both of which she did -- she minds very well!) and it was another Snickerdoodle I know the obvious thing to do is push everything back where she can't reach it -- but she can reach everywhere on the counter. We have tried pushing it back, it isn't enough. I mean, the other day my mom left a pan of bacon fat on the back of the stove after cooking. Nova must have been very quiet, because when she went in later it was all gone!

Now, I'm wondering, do scat mats work for dogs? I can't catch her in the act every time so scolding her for it is going to take a looong time to enforce the rules. Is there anything else you'd suggest if not scat mats?

[.sarah]

Or what about this? : Ssscat

I know how it works, but how does it tell if it's a person or an animal? Anyone used it before?

[Glacier]

I've used both. The scatmat was originally for the cats as Onyx likes to pee on the counter, but it worked for the occasional counter surfing husky too!
Then Onyx peed on the battery pack and that was the end of the scatmat!

Right now I have the ssscat thingy. It's fabulous! Doesn't seem to bother the dogs much, but they know that the beeping sound means trouble! I have a friend who put three of them under her Christmas tree and her lab puppy won't go near the tree! It can't tell the difference between animal or human though. Any motion sets it off.

[Vette]

Never heard of them before.
sounds like they work good though

[BitsyNaceyDog]

I've used the scat mat and it worked wonderfully. I got it to keep the cats off the counter and it worked great. Then when I got Nacey she learned how to jump onto the counter. I know that sounds odd, she's a 13lb. pug, but she loved to be on the counter and always seemed to find a way up onto them. I got the scat mat out and she quickly learned that counter tops were not a place she wanted to be. I think I kept the scat mat on the counter for about a week, just in case she tried to get up there, but after the first day or so I probably could have taken it off. She's never tried to get up there again.

Another option (and probably a cheaper one) is to use Snappy Trainers. I've never used them, but they're supposed to work.

[Giselle]

I used a different method (less pricy and more "hands-on" training, imo).

I know Giselle is a certified counter-surfer and will steal anything so, being the evil mom I am, I set her up. I placed a handful of pennies in these shallow plastic cups and placed the cups on a paper plate. I took a durable doggie cookie and punched a hole in the middle and strung the cookie to the plate. I left the room, and Giselle completely fell for the trick. The minute I heard a splashing/thrashing noise, I came in and cleaned up the mess (be sure to pick up the cookie before the dog has a chance to recuperate and eat it). I didn't scold her or anything. The shock and fright of the pennies was enough punishment. After two more "mistakes", Giselle never counter surfed again. You should only set up this predicament when you can be there to train or, otherwise, the dog will recuperate from the shock and eat the cookie. When you're not going to be able to keep an eye on the dog, I'd suggest clearing EVERYTHING from the table and placing it in the fridge or in a cupboard or, better yet, you could even crate the pup. Good luck!

[buttercup132]

i say use both of them