What is the opinion on Nutro Max cat food? I bought a box today at the pet store to try out. It is called "Nutro Max Cat Gourmet Classics Lite" in roated chicken flavor. I got lite because I want Puff to lose a few pounds. Will it hurt my other kitties whom are very slim and trim, to eat a lite food? I tried it out tonight, the kitties all liked it EXCEPT for Puff, figures

Is it a good brand? Is there something better? Is IIams or Science diet better? I tried science diet, and they HATED IT. Except the hairball control morsels, and they dont really get hairballs ever. Maybe 2 in their whole lives together.