So this really is YOUR Lil Eli that I came across on Petfinder when I was looking for tuxies for Cataholic!
Here is the full listing for him, I thought it was a weird coincidence that someone else had an Eli that looked like yours.
Eli's Petfinder ad
I really think he belongs with you and I checked that option above.
I hope that you can keep him and your money too but if you have to give them the $45 to shut them up!
Eli is your cat and he belongs with you!