This thread has left a big lump in my throat, poor caramel, if only he had not been neglected, its a very sad outcome , but i hate the thought of him having to have suffered and continue to do so, you did the right thing, bless you both, and i believe in my heart he knew that, take comfort in knowing you gave Caramel the loving he deserved and was there for his last moments. You are both very brave and i admire your courage, thank you for caring so much and of course for taking Sooty (Treacle).