Well after watching the show last night, i reckon both of them were lacking in a couple of songs, their last ones did it though for both of them, but Clay baby u ROCK, i honestly dont see one creepy thing about him, and i really looked hard.
I dont think it will be judged on how they look, and to be honest i agree with Simons comments to clay , u were ugly and now you are handsome, besides Rueben is a very large man, and that would be unfair to judge him on that, and say hey u cant be the American Idol because u are too fat even though u have an amazing voice.
Well they are both great singers , and both will do well in the future, and all i can say MAY THE BEST MAN WIN CLAY BABY