Thank you all for this wonderful information! I greatly appreciate this. Well im not too sure i would use the rubbing the nose teqniqe in it but i will try the crate thing.. First my puppy is 3 months old.. And yes we have a crate for her. We used to yell at her when she would go n the house but i must make sure i do the crate teqniuqe. And doing the crate that will eventually make her understand she is not allowed to go in the house?? Well im am happy that now i know how to do it properly without hurting her.. Thanks !