Smudgy is beautiful, but I see two cats in picture (one with a bow tie). Which one is Smudgy?

Many moons ago, we founded a kitten on a rainy night under a car in a parking lot. The poor thing was huddled with his tail in a puddle of water. We picked him up, and, like Smudgy, Beanie grew into a wonderful cat. Stories with happy ending like Smudgy's always remind of him.