Which necklace?

[Litterati]

It is timeless and all-age appropriate. IMHO simple is better.

[Cataholic]

I go with understated over and over again.

[cassiesmom]

I think the one on the right would be a very special keepsake. To me it is not too gaudy, just a different style than the one on the left. I'm still a "girly girl" even at my age, so I am going to part from the previous voters and opt for the one on the right Either way, what a special gift!

[Taz_Zoee]

If she liked the simplicity of the necklace you were wearing then I'd say go with the small simple heart. Personally I like that one much better. I just don't dress up fancy enough to really wear the pink one too much......but that's me.

[Asiel]

I would go with the simple heart, the first one. More age appropriate and something that she can treasure even as she gets older-- she can wear it with just about anything and look very classy. The other one is a bit ornate for my taste.

[caseysmom]

I started this thread then went mia sorry about that my whole family got hit with the flu. My daughter voted for the small heart too I think I will go with that but I also like the pink one too. Its from Macys too which has an easy return policy so she can change it for something else if she wants.

[gini]

Without question, I like the plain silver heart the best. It just is plain and classy and a perfect gift
for a 13 year old.

[carole]

Yes i agree the simpler first one is more suitable for a 13 yr old, although i love the second one myself, but then i am an old girl lol.