Which necklace?

[caseysmom]

Thank you thats exactly what I thought but my husband liked the other one but he tends to like more ornate things I agree I think the other one is more appropriate but I needed another opinion.

[Karen]

The plain one that is real silver will last her for many years, and go with more outfits, and as it is real silver, something she can treasure as her first piece of real grown-up jewelry.

[Kirsten]

The first one is timeless, and I think she could wear it in combination with all kinds of clothes, also later as an adult. The second one is really girly and looks cute; but it needs to be matching with her dressing style...

[pomtzu]

I'd go with the plain one too. More age appropriate and something she can wear at any age.


ETA: If she really wants something with a small gemstone in it, Penney's has a lot of the small heart/gemstone ones right now with Valentine's Day next week. I saw some with red stones and also purple for the Feb birthstone.

[Litterati]

It is timeless and all-age appropriate. IMHO simple is better.

[Cataholic]

I go with understated over and over again.

[cassiesmom]

I think the one on the right would be a very special keepsake. To me it is not too gaudy, just a different style than the one on the left. I'm still a "girly girl" even at my age, so I am going to part from the previous voters and opt for the one on the right Either way, what a special gift!

[Taz_Zoee]

If she liked the simplicity of the necklace you were wearing then I'd say go with the small simple heart. Personally I like that one much better. I just don't dress up fancy enough to really wear the pink one too much......but that's me.