Wow, how ridiculous. Some people just like to cause trouble. My Skya is really skinny, she just doesn't gain weight. It doesn't help that she's really not very interested in eating, but even when she does it she burns it off too fast to gain any weight. I give her as much food as Nebo (60 lbs) and Keva (45 lbs), and she weighs 28 lbs. She rarely eats all of it though. The vet has said she's healthy, she must have a little layer of fat because you can't see her ribs through her coat but you sure can feel them easily. Some dogs just stay skinny just like some dogs are really prone to being overweight.