Sorry.. no recommendations as I'm not sure what Petsmart carries and our food is a bit pricey compared to Nutro I think. If it's something that doesn't absolutely have to be from Petsmart, I'd recommend Chicken Soup for the Dog Lover's Soul. It's comparable in price with great ingredients. I now feed my guys Acana because their ingredients are slightly better and they have a Sport & Agility formula for Keeva, but my crew did great on CS!

Unrelated, when did you move to BC?? Where abouts are you?