Quote Originally Posted by Karen View Post
You are generalizing here as much as she was. I have never heard that "most" breeders remove dewclaws, in fact all our dogs have had them intact, and I never remember meeting a dog without them.

I do not believe any petition will succeed in banning declawing. Education, education, and education will. With any surgery there are risks and good and bad surgeons as well. I have know declawed cats that we fine and normal, and ones that were not.

I would never declaw a cat - but I am terribly allergic to them, so cannot own one anyway. I do dissuade anyone who talks about it from ever getting it done, and that is what everyone should do - educate, educate, educate.


I dont think I was generalizing. Just going by my own experience. I post on 3 Labrador Retriever message boards and majority of the breeders on there, and they are the responsible ones who do all the health clearances prior to breeding, remove the declaws. Many of us are friends and attend the "Labfest" had twice a year, its very very common. The 3 Labs next door are show dogs, champion lines and they do not have declaws either. I cant speak for the dogs and breeders you have met, only my own. From my understanding, Schnauser grow them on the hind legs and majority responsible breeders remove the declaw when they are puppies too. Its common. So is docking tails and cutting half of certain breeds ears off, isnt it? Boxers have their tails docked, so do Dobermans is that generalizing?

Dogs are unjustly doctored too. Which was my point.