Whale Wars?

[Karen]

We watch it. It annoys me sometimes that the captain's name is too close to my sweetheart's name - I would never want them to be confused. I think they are doing a good thing, but with weird and often questionable tactics.

[Giselle]

I think they are doing a good thing, but with weird and often questionable tactics.

Exactly my thoughts. I watched the entire season up until 3 am LOL. I think it's a fascinating and inspiring show and the captain's intentions are certainly laudable. However, throwing butyric acid at the ship? I understand that they're trying to taint the meat, but...isn't there a better way? Maybe not; I just thought it was weird. I've had to work with butyric acid before, and that stuff is ATROCIOUS. And the slippery bomb things? What? What is the purpose of that? I must have missed the explanation.

Then again, there's only so much you can do to ward off offenders without resorting to, well, all out violence.

BTW, the ship's name is Nisshin Maru. Also, I would hesitate to write these blanket generalizations:

The Japanese have absolutely no respect for living beings. It angers me.

The Japanese, as a collective group, are quite innovative and represent a modern, progressive population. Culturally, they dine on items that we may find deplorable, and the animal rights movement there is vastly different from ours. But I would not say that they have absolutely no respect for living beings. That's quite an angering statement for me to read, honestly..

[RICHARD]

The paper bombs contained flour- their explanation was that when wet, the flour made the the decks slippery.

I have to say that the tactics were a little strange and the complaints about the retaliation were stranger.

I have to say that the whole scenario reminds me of the protests at the G8 summits. It's O.K. to burn, break and destroy, until the cops come by and beat the living crap outta you.


----------

The story about the bullet/BPV was a little suspicious.

The whole purpose of a BPV is to dissapate the shock of a bullet strike.
Captain Ahab just had a pin prick from the badge? Usually the wearer of a BPV has a large hematoma or bruise from a bullet strike, the range that the supposed shot was fired from would have at least knocked the captain about....and notice the glance at the camera man when the doc was trying to remove the slug-it was almost a "hey, got this in tape" moment?

HMMMMMMMM....

[Karen]

Richard, I did a little digging - I believe it is Methyl Cellulose, not flour in the paper "bombs" they throw. As I know well, flour get sticky when wet, not slipperier! You can make GLUE with flour + water!

From Wikipedia: Methyl cellulose (or methylcellulose) is a chemical compound derived from cellulose. It is a hydrophilic white powder in pure form and dissolves in cold (but not in hot) water, forming a clear viscous solution or gel. It is sold under a variety of trade names and is used as a thickener and emulsifier in various food and cosmetic products, and also as a treatment of constipation. Like cellulose, it is not digestible, not toxic, and not allergenic.

[pomtzu]

I've watched a few episodes, but just can't seem to get in to it on a regular basis. I'm waiting for the new season of Deadliest Catch - I'm absolutely addicted to that series! Has anyone heard when it will be back?

[moosmom]

The bombs were made of paper and ransid butter, which smelled awful and made the decks slippery. It actually brought the whaling ship to a standstill.

Don't know much about the skipper wanting fortune and fame in front of the television camera. I'll have to watch it more closely and reserve my opinion till then.

[Karen]

The bombs were made of paper and ransid butter, which smelled awful and made the decks slippery. It actually brought the whaling ship to a standstill.

Don't know much about the skipper wanting fortune and fame in front of the television camera. I'll have to watch it more closely and reserve my opinion till then.

They throw two "weapons" - glass bottles of buteric acid (from rancid butter), and the other thing they throw is the methyl cellulose, in paper packages wrapped with tape that burst upon hitting the other ship. It is powder that forms a gel when it gets wet, so is very difficult to wash away. So the buteric acid is the "stinky" and the cellulose" is the "slippery" - just a clarification!

[RICHARD]

Richard, I did a little digging - I believe it is Methyl Cellulose, not flour in the paper "bombs" they throw. As I know well, flour get sticky when wet, not slipperier! You can make GLUE with flour + water!

From Wikipedia: Methyl cellulose (or methylcellulose) is a chemical compound derived from cellulose. It is a hydrophilic white powder in pure form and dissolves in cold (but not in hot) water, forming a clear viscous solution or gel. It is sold under a variety of trade names and is used as a thickener and emulsifier in various food and cosmetic products, and also as a treatment of constipation. Like cellulose, it is not digestible, not toxic, and not allergenic.

Thanks.

I was watching with one ear and thought I heard that one of the DHs say it was flour.

I stand corrected.

-----------

Another point that Ahab made was that he had "Never seen a whale killed" in all the time he had been campaining? I guess he don't watch the videos that are shown all during the show?

-----------

MY last 'thing' about the show is the "Steve Irwin" named ship.

Irwin, while a little outrageous in the way he promoted animal welfare, NEVER tried to use strong arm tactics to get the point across. He was more into the educating the masses and getting the message out.

I feel by using SI's name that captain Nemo is disparaging the work Irwin did, and naming the boat is a ploy to get the, "Oh, It's a GOOD cause!" feelings out there.

[RICHARD]

I just caught the latest episode of WW and had to shake my head at this season's campaign.

Last night two of the ships collided, again.

So the captain gets his crew to man a water cannon they had installed on their ship, toss more stink bombs and I noticed one crew member standing next to wall/bulkhead with tube in his hand.

It took me about two seconds to realize he was shining a laser at the Japanese boat.

I guess he didn't read the warning on every hand held laser pointer made.

Moron.


-----------

Again, I do not like whale hunting, but I cannot get behind the idea that 'anything goes' while trying to stop it.

I can really imagine the up roar that the good old captain would raise if one of HIS crew was seriously hurt that way.

Buffoon.

[aTailOf2Kitties]

I'm with you on this one Richard. I watch this show just to see the whale-hugging sea hippies do stupid stuff and then whine about the consequences Their hearts are in the right place, but they sure don't act like they have any brains sometimes. Go ahead, wreck another boat... you'll just keep spinning the story until you find a bunch of goody-goody rich idiots to fix it or buy another one.