I would definitely look at getting a new vet, BUT would go by word of mouth! I would ask at pet stores, and if there are several vets near you, take Sheena along and phone to ask about dropping in and just saying hello. You can get a good "feel" just by being there.

OR - I bet your vet back where you moved from would be able to recommend a vet or two. Maybe there is someone there he/she went to vet school with, and who is awesome. Plus your vet knows you, and would be able to hazard a good guess for a new vet.