Jenn, you have done this fostering for some time now, and you are great at it. So go with your instincts! You have placed some pets through PetSmart, if I remember right; and you have found great homes for pets. So it works for some not for others, that is the great part of the FOSTER system. YOU get to know the personalities, not only to tell potential adoptors, but to make sure the cat is cared for in the best way possible even prior to adoption.