Cat food question - Maxximum Nutrition?

[Jessika]

Oh really? Why is that? Just curious, I feed all Nurto personally, but my SIL feeds the Maxximum dog food and swears by it.

I fed it to my pups for a week or so when we ran out of their normal stuff and couldn't make it to Springfield (the nearest petsmart or food stores that sold Nutro and its a 45 minute drive one-way) and it was just AWFUL. They pooped about 6x more than normal (I kid you not), and it smelled like something died! Not to mention they were always hungry and I was only feeding the recommended amount (which was, like, 2 1/2 or three cups per dog a day). And no, it wasn't because I didn't "transition" them over to the new food because I did lol

I don't know, I just did NOT have good or desireable results on it

[JenBKR]

I fed it to my pups for a week or so when we ran out of their normal stuff and couldn't make it to Springfield (the nearest petsmart or food stores that sold Nutro and its a 45 minute drive one-way) and it was just AWFUL. They pooped about 6x more than normal (I kid you not), and it smelled like something died! Not to mention they were always hungry and I was only feeding the recommended amount (which was, like, 2 1/2 or three cups per dog a day). And no, it wasn't because I didn't "transition" them over to the new food because I did lol

I don't know, I just did NOT have good or desireable results on it

Oh wow, really? That's definitely not a good sign for that food!

I talked to sis a little bit ago, and I told her that I'd give her a little Nutro to try (don't know why I didn't think of that before). Maybe it will work, maybe not, we'll have to see. I did just find out too that she feeds her dog Dad's, which can't be a good brand either, so I'm giving her a little dog food too. Hopefully all goes well and she'll switch, otherwise maybe I'll recommend the Petsmart brand. Thanks all!