I alsoo have two wedding rings. Never had an engagement ring so my husband bought me a diamond about 7 years ago. My wedding ring is a thicker band with sort of a nugget look, so it really can't be worn with the diamond. When I want to wear the diamond on my left hand, I wear my grandmother's plain gold band with it. My original wedding band will always be the one of most importance to me.

Your new rings are beautiful but I personally prefer the style of your original rings. Cherish both sets.