Nope, I don't think you're off base. As hubby says "He got the geek vote". I think he has a nice voice, but nothing to compare to the others, and his image is TERRIBLE. As the show progresses he gets more and more full of himself (to put it politely.) Just wait for the week he's voted off - your jaw will hit the ground with how arrogant he is!

I think all of the remaining three have a great presence and will make a great American Idol. I am very impressed with Vonzell, as she wasn't this good in the beginning. I seriously thought she'd be voted off long ago, but she keeps coming back stronger and stronger. So who knows?

But, I want Bo to win. Hes soooooo cute. And I typically don't go for that look, but man does he carry it off!