I must say, I've been in your shoes!

We live in a 2 story townhouse, 2 bedrooms . . . We have 2 cats and only one litterbox. So far, so good! Of course it's a littermaid which cuts out a lot of the work & mess for us . . . but like I said, it's working.

I would imagine that when we buy a house, we'll get another littermaid . . . but for the space we have, one is enough for our two cats.

I would definitely suggest a playmate for Don Juan! We got Brodie as a playmate for Josie and I'm soooo happy that we did! They love each other so much!

Only suggestion I have is that you should get a cat of the opposite sex & younger than Don Juan. Might make it easier on him.

Good luck & keep us posted as to what you're gonna do!!!