From my understanding the Halti and Gentle Leader are similar, but some people I have talked with say the gentle leader is better made...it seems to fit the muzzle better and is harder to get off.

I have tried the Halti with Cincy many times...she has had it on for short time periods, walks and been givin treats with it on, all that. She still constantly tries to get it off when walking. She has scraped her nose numerous times and once got it off her nose and was chewing on it while we were walking. That is why I was considering the gentle leader, to see if maybe it would stay in position better. It was surprising to me she has had such a time adjusting, cause as with many other dogs, Sadie adapted just fine and it makes a HUGE difference with her.

I guess I may see if I can test a gentle leader next time we go in for a class and see how that works...I'll let ya know!