Some good and bad news:

Elrond is gone. He was adopted yesterday.

On the bright side, my dad is completely for the idea now. He says if that's what we want, it's fine with him.
Sooo:

My mom was on the phone with the lady from the shelter, and she said they have PLENTY of other kittens down there for us to pick out of. She also said that since Sally is older, she would not want to bother much with a kitten. She suggested getting a male pair of cats, so they would have each other to play with. So...

WE'RE GETTING TWO MALE KITTENS!!! On Wednesday we're visiting the shelter. (They may not be Tuxies though..)
Wish us luck!
Three cats...wowie! Guess I'll be hanging out in the Cat section more.
Britt