I've had Sebastian (domestic short-hair-male) for 3 1/2 years now- since he was a little kitten. He has been my baby and I spoil him rotten- i will admit. My boyfriend treated him like his baby, too- until one horrible night. We were sleeping while he got a terrible charlie horse in the middle of the night. Through much of his agony and yelling, I tried to help him get the knot out of his leg. Then all of a sudden, Sebastian, comes violently attacking him- something he had NEVER done before! I couldn't get him off, he was literally hanging from my boyfriend's skin and continued to stalk him, hiss, and meow this crazy meow. It was awful, blood was everywhere... I finally shewed him into a different room, closed the door, and helped my boyfriend clean his wounds. About 20 minutes later, I let Sebastian out of the guest bedroom and he was purring, head butting me and showing me a great amount of affection like nothing had happened. He proceeded to want to cuddle with my boyfriend, too. It took me awhile to get him to feel comfortable with Sebastian again- but over time we even let him back in the bedroom to sleep with us again.
About 7 months later, we were sleeping again and Sebastian attacked him. The three of us were laying there and my boyfriends cell phone alarm went off for us to get up- so I kind of nudged him to turn it off- all of a sudden.. dej ja vu... It was the charlie horse situation all over again without the charlie horse- this time my boyfriend ended up w/ scar tissue.
I don't understand what provokes this behavior in my cat- but now my boyfriend is so afraid to be around him and will not sleep over anymore. We tried just closing the door but neither of us get sleep because Sebastian cries and scratches at the door all night. My boyfriend basically told me that if he is to propose to me, he wants the cat gone; that he cannot live his life walking on egg shells and being afraid of the cat. It hurts because the 3 of us were such a good "family." He always helped me out w/ him- and he loved him.... Now he absolutely hates him, and who could blame him? I don't want to get rid of my cat- he loves me and is so attached- vice versa. I couldn't bear the thought of giving him away for adoption or putting him down. My boyfriend also made the point that he didn't want our kids around the cat someday because he would be afraid of what he would do to them. Does anybody have some words of wisdom for me? I'm completely torn.... :(