Electronic pets: Good or bad?

[Miss Z]

I thought this would make an interesting thread.

Yesterday, the shelter I volunteer at was in the newspaper, because it is at this time when all the unwanted pets who were bought as easter presents start to get dumped. :( Today when I went in, every single pen for every type of animal is full. I've never seen so many unwanted animals before, it really is very sad.

Also, on the news a few days ago, a report by the RSPCA read that unwanted animals are up 44% for 2006 compared to 2005. That is one heck of an increase. And who knows how 2007 will compare?

In the newpaper report, the manageress of our shelter blamed electronic pets for the increase. Because these creations, whether toys or video games, can be switched off when not needed, don't cost anything to care for, don't need cleaning up after and co-operate willingly with their 'owners', they have become more appealing than the real thing. A child sitting at home would much rather muck out their virtual pony with one click of a button than go and clean out their bunny sitting in a week's worth of dirty bedding.

I never really thought about electronic pets being a cause of neglect before. I always put them in quite a bright light, as they were the option of owning a 'pet' for those that cannot own a real one. However, now I'm not so sure. Perhaps they are mechanical monsters killing the tradition of children and pets being the best of friends.

What do you think?

[Zippy]

Electronic pets like neopets and nindendogs are made to be a fun relexing games.I love video games and think the electronic pet games are great and fun.I don't blame them for more animals in shelters.Tamagotci and Pets computer games have been out for years before nintendogs and pony friends.Anyone remember the Tamagotci and Gigi pet crazy?

[mrspunkysmom]

I can't blame them for pet abuse or abadonment. If someone is likely to abandon an animal, then any excuse will do.

E-pets are upposed ot be fun and could be good for those that can't have animals.

If e-pets is a good way to ahve an animal without the mess, then i hope that person doesn't have children.

and people abandon other electronic creations too. Does anyone know the lifespan of a web membership, let alone a blog or a real website? I know it isn't long.

Anne

[IRescue452]

Another scapegoat. Adults are responsible for bringing pets into the home, and are ultimately responsible for their care, not a 12 year old. I blame the ease at which pets can be produced and purchased.

[Twisterdog]

I think it's probably a big stretch to think that electronic pets influence real pet ownership at all.

If a person is inclined to treat a real pet well, letting an electronic pet die isn't going to matter. And visa versa.

I take very good care of my real critters. But I slaughtered several electronic ones! Oops. :o

I think it's like saying playing a video game is going to make a kid go out and shoot people. I think not.

[Kfamr]

A VERY big stretch. I have Gigapets, Nintendogs, etc burried somewhere in my closet. However, there's no way in heck I'd abandon my dogs. Rather silly for them to blame electronic pets.

[mike001]

I don't like them. I feel it gives people the impression that real pets can be shoved away when the novelty wears off. As always, our shelters are also full of easter pups that are no longer wanted.

[lute]

It's kind of a toss up for me. The games could be good for kids than cannot own their own animals due to allergies, parental rules, etc. I also agree that the games can take up time that someone could be useing on their own living animals. I stopped playing all the Nintendogs, Neopets, catz, and Dogz games once I thought "Hey, couldn't I be useing this time to care for my real living pets?"

[columbine]

They're much better for most of the people out there who THINK they want a real pet! Children who assume their parents will take care of the pet when they tire of it, corporate whores who sign up for biennial transfers, people who date/marry allergic people or animal haters, and the vast majority of pet owners who get a pet without giving any thought to the investment of time, money, and lifestyle they'd have to make to raise the pet ethically.

One in particular, Paro the robotic baby seal (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paro_(robot)), has also proven an ideal companion for the frail elderly, who can't really take care of a pet but need a cute fix and a cuddle to cheer them up!

Love, Columbine

[Argranade]

I want to buy a bunch of Furbies one day and BLOW THEM UP!

Muwhahahahaa! :D

[KittyGurl]

I think that they are great. When I first got Ninetendogs, it felt like I had a real dog. I would take it everywhere and play it whenever I could. I learn a lot just from playing that game. These games build up good ownership skills and they are really fun!

[KittyGurl]

I want to buy a bunch of Furbies one day and BLOW THEM UP!

Muwhahahahaa! :D


LOL

[Taz_Zoee]

My 13 year old niece has Nintendogs and the idog (I think it's called). While she loves playing those games, she would never trade it for her real animals. The family has two dogs and my niece has a rabbit that is completely her responsibility. But like someone else stated.....it all comes down to how the child is parented. Yeah, my niece needs to be reminded to feed her rabbit or clean out the cage, but a reminder is all it takes and she jumps up to do it.
Anyway, I voted they were good.

[Kalei]

Well I picked neutral because I don't think they can teach good ownership of a real pet, but I think they are great to just have fun with and play with and great for kids who are not allowed to have real pets.

At one time I was the Electronic pet Queen lol. I had over 20, and I still have around 15. I still love them so much and every once and awhile I even put one on and take care of it lol and I'm 20 years old. I've been addicted to them all my life, and I take good care of them too:D

I just think they are very fun and a great hobby for your extra time:)

[Catlady711]

Another scapegoat. Adults are responsible for bringing pets into the home, and are ultimately responsible for their care, not a 12 year old. I blame the ease at which pets can be produced and purchased.


I TOTALLY agree! I just cringe everytime someone comes in to our hospital with a puppy or kitten and say they got it for the 4 year old kid standing next to them. *shivers*

I'm not saying some kids are not responsible enough to take care of pets, some are but it's not at any specific age, it's based upon their past history of taking care of things on time and consistently, and the kid being old enough to actually take care of the animal properly. Otherwise I figure if the adult wants the pet ok, but don't get one 'just for the kids'.

[Pembroke Welsh Corgis love me]

I don't think electronic pets are good they should of never been made

[flipgirl]

I think there are a lot of people out there who should have electronic children as well..they'd do a lot better job!

Electronic pets are fine - I think the tamaguchis (sp?) are great in teaching kids responsibility.

However, it is sad to see all those animals stuck in shelters and no where to go. If I had the money and the time, I'd adopt them all! I think mixing breeds for the sake of money and the lack of commitment and research from people who get a dog for the wrong reasons like they think a dog is cute are why there are so many. I can't say I don't agree with mixed breeds as long as breeders are doing it for the sake of improving a breed. Bulldogs are really a mixed breed if you go long way into their history. Purebreds are suffering from a shrinking gene pool and there are also those breeders breeding purebreds with defective genes for money.

Having said that, it is great that there are shelters for these animals and wonderful people who take their time, money and love to care for them. Blaming electronic pets is just another way of escaping responsibility.