I will first start out by saying I HATE tidy cats. The few times I've gotten it I've just hated it, it doesn't clump every well at all. LOL I have to keep reminding myself how much I hate it because sometimes I forget and pick it up at the store then get upset because it doesn't clump well.

I usually use Scoop Away, I think it works well and keeps the other under control. My other two favorites are arm & hammer and fresh step.