ITA with you Cincy'sMom - try all other methods and if they don't work, go with the pinch collar. Nice to see someone other than me has had to use this. It looks so much crueler than it is. Our late Westie was a puller from day one and we used the pinch collar on him, with looks of hate from others. If someone said something I would take the collar off and demonstrate how it felt on my, and then their arm, adding that the dog also has a coat if fur between it and the prongs! And yes, harnesses only encourage pulling. What do you put on an animal that you WANT to pull? A harness!

The kind that goes over the nose is called a gentle leader. Didn't work for us either.