pat i have decided in my head that vet has made an incorrect diagnosis, yes maybe it is wishful thinking on my part, but hey it does happen,ellie has been pretty darn good today, so i am keeping my hopes up, i am not going to write her off just yet, as i said i will wait to see the vet i really trust, not that the other is not a good vet, she is, but she always seems to differ in opinion from mine, so we shall see.