I have enjoyed using California Natural (Reduced Calorie) for almost a year, and my girls have thrived. Unfortunately, the distributors are inconsistent and many times when my local feed store would order it, it wouldn't come in. This got so bad, I switched to Innova Senior, which he keeps in stock. Now, we're having the same problem with that one too! They are made by the same company.

So, we have converted to Bil Jac (not on your list), Reduced Calorie formula, and the girls love it!! It is a quality food, sort of expensive, but worth it.

Logan