Thank you so much for your replies, everyone! I have no idea why my mind skipped over trying to go straight to dry food (or moist dry food). I guess since the four permanent cats at our house are little piggies when it comes to wet food that I forget some cats are not too fond of it. I will certainly be trying what is suggested.

I figured everyone would wean at their own rates. The stubborn girl is no longer taking the bottle well and I feel guilty for not trying any other options sooner...

Anyhow, thanks again!