Okay, there are 16 E's, 4 S's, and 7 A's.

- ---e -e---e- --- -- -a-e a ---- -e-a-se s-e -as-'- e----e- -- -ee- -- ---.
- -ea-, ---s -a- ---e --- -a----- -- -ee- -- ----e-.

Logan - E(16) = 32
sammi - S(4) = 4
Rottie - A(7) = 14

Letters left to choose from:
BCDFGHIJKLMNOPQRTUVWXYZ