Happy Birthday, Starr!!!
You were such a little cutie pie that I can easily see how your meowmy fell in love with you so easily.

Tracey, as for Starr's weight, kitties do tend to "fill out" in their second year of life. It's like the grow "up" during the first year, then "out" during the second year. But even if he doesn't, he might just be a small cat. CJ is only about 9 lbs at 8 years old. CJ always seems skinny to me, but that's because I'm used to tubby male cats like Tubby, and I know you're used to bigger males too. I think as long as they eat good and are active, "fit & trim" is better for them anyway.