I had the same thing happen with Orange Blossom.I knew he was Morris from up the Street but the Drunks wouldnt let him stay in.I let him stay nights sometimes,and I put him out in the Morning.
It was like Fred Flinstone putting Dino out,as he didnt want to leave.
But I didnt want to be accused of stealing Cats.And then One Day,I found Orange Blossom dead on my lawn,coming to what he dearly wanted to be his home!
I wish I had let him sleep over that day,every day I wish I had let him stay in.