I just went back and read your original thread and I know that the vet recommended that food but why? Are they overweight?

My cats are on a low-protein diet and they did not like the food either. In the end, and as I do now, I give them a scoop of the LP wet food and spread a thin layer of Fancy Feast on top and that seems to do the trick.

On the finicky days, they lick the FF off the top and cry for more so I give them a bit more but mix it in with the LP stuff. It's hard I know.

Do what you think is right. At 8 and 9 years old, old habits are hard to break and if they are doing fine then why change?