American Idol Season 5

[jazzcat]

Elliott is the man! I thought he did great and so did Chris.

I thought the judges were kind of hard on Katherine. I don't really care for her, like .sarah it's an attitude thing, but she wasn't that bad tonight.

Please, can Kellie leave now!?!

[*JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*]

Katherine-I usually don't care to much about her either but I thought she did really good tonight! For like the first time I really enjoyed her but the judges didnt

Elliot- Did really well I thought, he is a true idol but not many ppl seem to care for him. My Mom loveeees him!

Kelly- I use to love her but she isnt progressing, she can't get out of her comfort zone and isnt able to do other styles of music. I think her time has come.

Taylor- I just love him, he did alright tonight, but just alright.

Paris- I don't like her at all and never have. Her performance was alright I guess but it was to old for her.

Chris- I never really bothered with him but man did he do good tonight Omg I just loved his performance and especially after the past couple of weeks, this pulls him out of danger I think! Plus he sang my fav song and Brian Adams is Canadian

Bottom 3:
Paris (will go)
Kelly (should go by her performances)
Katherine

[christa]

Oh WOW!!! I think Chris was singing that love song to me, LOL . . . wait, I'm married, oh yeah . . . that's right . . . so is he . . . LOLOLOL . . . guess he IS good! Shew, was he EVER good last night!!! Okay, enough about Chris.

Kat: She's really beautiful but I think Randy & the judges were right about the song being too big for her. She *tried* but I don't think she really pulled it off. She has an awesome voice but I wish that she'd back it down a bit. Not try quite that hard.

Elliot: He is such a sweetie and I thought he did fantastic tonight! I really hope he stays!!! He has such a unique voice! I just love listening to him! I would be really interested to see what kind of an album he would come out with!

Kellie: Poor girl . . . she just hasn't been doing well. Last night was the worst yet. Unless she just has a crazy fan base, I can't see her going much further after that. (that and she's currently on "votefortheworst.com") . . . maybe that's why she's still hanging in there.

Taylor: I always love Taylor . . . for some reason, I just love his voice. Maybe it's my bluegrass/country/KY roots. I don't know. I just love his southern feel. I enjoyed his performance tonight, although it wasn't my favorite. I still can't imagine him being in the bottom 3.

Paris: I haven't liked her from the beginning. I like her speaking voice, I hate her singing voice. She tries to sound like a 40 year old and she looks like a 15 year old. Paris - your time is coming.

The bottom 3 will be . . . Paris, Kellie & Kat.

I hope that Kellie or Paris goes tonight. Either would be fine with me.

[Dixieland Dancer]

My bottom three picks are: Kelli (I think she should go tonight), Paris and Taylor (sadly because I like Him).

I did not agree with the judges about Katherine. I thought she sounded good and I did not compare her to Whitney Houston. I just enjoyed her perfomance.

Kelli was very weak. Chris did a very good job but Elliot was the best. It even brought Paula Abdul to tears (which had me in tears ).

[krazyaboutkatz]

Chris is still my favorite and I thought that he performed very well last night. I tried to vote for him but couldn't get through and then I forgot to try again.

My bottom 3 picks are Kellie, Taylor, and Paris. Even though I like Kellie's personality, her voice just isn't strong enough to win this competition. It's time for her to go.

[Felix]

Bye Bye Pickler

[christa]

Well, I hated to see Kellie go but I think she was definitely in line next. I mean, at this point, everyone is great. They all have star potential IMO. There can only be ONE though . . .

Kellie's performance last night was pretty terrible . . . I think she'd do fine sticking with country/bluegrass. Who knows.

What is the theme for next week? Did they ever say??? I missed that part!

[elizabethann]

Well, I hated to see Kellie go but I think she was definitely in line next. I mean, at this point, everyone is great. They all have star potential IMO. There can only be ONE though . . .

Kellie's performance last night was pretty terrible . . . I think she'd do fine sticking with country/bluegrass. Who knows.

What is the theme for next week? Did they ever say??? I missed that part!

Somebody on the AI board said they'll be singing 2 songs. One will be billboard and the other is a song from the year they were born.

[Roxyluvsme13]

I wanted Paris to go, but oh well. Kellie didn't do so hot last night.

[flamepony12]

I'm so glad Kellie and Ace are gone. Hopefully Taylor will be next.

[.sarah]

Surprised it wasn't Paris, since no one seems to like her. I was getting sick of Kellie anyway.

[buckner]

I'm so glad Kellie and Ace are gone. Hopefully Taylor will be next.

Bite your tongue! Taylor deserves to stay, he's incredible.

I was a bit surprised that Kat or Paris didn't go tonight, honestly. Kellie has proven that she has a big fan base, so I didn't think she'd get the boot. But, it was her time to go, especially after last night and last week's performances. ACK! I hope Paris is next, and then Kat. I believe Chris will win (he's good and all, just not my favourite), but I really hope that Elliot or Taylor win. I doubt Taylor will win, but I really think him and Elliot are the real deals. <3

[Lobodeb]

I've missed the last two weeks, but due to a wonderful little thing called DVR, I was able to get caught up last night.

It was Kellie's time to go. Paula said it best when she said that she wasn't raising the bar each week.

The rest of the competition is going to get really interesting. The top 5 are all very, very talented.

[joanofark]

Aw poor kellie!! Bye bye!!

I want Paris then Elliot to go. I want Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the top 3.

[caseysmom]

I thought it was time for Kellie to go, Elliot is still my favorite. Taylor needs to go next, either him or Paris.