American Idol Season 5

[k9krazee]

Overall I'm happy with who left...for the guys I like Chris Daughtry, Kevin, Will and Taylor.
Can't stand 'Sway', I wish he would have been booted...

Girls, I like Kelly Pickler, Paris, and Lisa Tucker...I agree, I don't like Brenna at all!

[joanofark]

Overall I'm happy with who left...for the guys I like Chris Daughtry, Kevin, Will and Taylor.
Can't stand 'Sway', I wish he would have been booted...

Those are my favorite guys too! YES, 'Sway'- Needs to go!!

[Lobodeb]

Yeah, Brenna needs to go. Get over yourself girl and stop posing for the camera! Your attitude will get you no where.

I too like Tayor. That picture that .sarah posted makes Taylor look like George Clooney! Wow! I like Chris too and I'm sorry, but Ace's face makes me a little weak in the knees.

Of the ladies, I like Kellie (cuteness factor), Mandesa, Katherine, Lisa and Paris. The top 12 should should be loaded with talent.

I agreed with everyone that got voted off.

[rosethecopycat]

Let's talk about the best vocalists here, and only about vocals.

The best singers are: Mandisa, Chris D., Taylor, Elliot.

Close behind are: Paris, Sway, Gedeon.

Better than I thought were: Ace, Ayla.

In the general pack are the rest, with the exception of:

Kevin, Bucky and Stevie whose vocals are just not good enough, they need to go.


Now, let's talk about 'show' or 'it factor' :

Paris, Gedeon, Chris D., Taylor, Ayla

The only ones that are at the top of the vocals and 'it' are Chris D. and Taylor

That's where my guess is now for winner.


If you eliminate the cute factor then:
Kevin, Kellie, Ace, (the one who looks like Peter Brady) is it Will?
they all must go. (but not right now)

I think I'm in for some surprises here, as many of you really like Kevin.
And as far as Brenna is concerned, she is not as bad of a singer as many, but she has some bad attitude. No 'show'.
Mandisa could fly under the radar and really take this thing, her vocals are so strong. If she could just get the personality happening.

Can anyone wager on the next set to go???????

[Anita Cholaine]

We are a bit delayed here in Argentina (we saw the girls performances on Wednesday and the guys yesterday) and I just read who has been eliminated... I'm happy that Brenna was one of them (I never liked her) I quite liked Heather's personality, but she definitely had to go. I'm sad for David and Sway I really liked them...

About my favourites: Girls, I think Katherine is awesome, and I also love Mandisa and Lisa Tucker... Kellie is not my idol anymore... I still love her personality, but....

And the guys... I absolutely LOVE Chris Daughtry; I love his voice, I love everything about him! I still love Taylor, and I think Will is just too cute (of course that he's a great singer too!)

And to finish this long boring post : I think a boy will win this year...

[.sarah]

And to finish this long boring post : I think a boy will win this year...

A boy named Chris! If he doesn't win then America is out of their minds!

[rosethecopycat]

I watched my TIVO a bit late.so, here it comes...

Obscene.

Sway was a much better vocalist than: Will (Peter Brady), Kevin, Bucky.

Additionally, I think Sway should have lasted longer than Ace, and possibly Gedeon.

Sway should have gotten 4th place, behind Chris, Elliot, Taylor.

Hands down. Sway sang a very challenging Stevie song and what does Peter Brady sing? Kenny Rogers? give me a break.
Sorry folks, Kevin may be cute but he does NOT have a very good instrument. His range is limited, he has not demonstated falsetto range, and he doesn't have any dynamic power (belt notes). In addition, his voice does not have a clear tone. I have no idea why he is still there.
Bucky, it sounds like you smoke 3 packs of Camels right before your sing. Getting tired of it.

By the way, Elliot sang a song that was absolutely phenonemal. Vocal gymnastics!

Taylor, you need to 'step it up' quickly now. You've got that raw soul, but you need to pick the right songs, or the other two guys are going to roll right over you.

Girls: I'm going with Mandisa now.

[Lobodeb]

Any predictions on who's getting the boot?

If it were up to me, I'd say for the ladies, Kinnik and Ayla.

From the guys, Will and Kevin.

What do you all think?

[k9krazee]

Not sure about the girls, I haven't really been watching them

The guys...I really like Will, I don't want to see him go but he probably will. I also think its time for Kevin to leave, or possibly Bucky...

[zoomer]

Taylor is AAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWESOME!

[joanofark]

OMG!!!!!!!! 2 WORDS!!!!!

Chris Rocked!!!!!!!!!

He was awesome tonight I loved the song and all!!!!

Accually, Ace did ok for me this time (I didn't have to hold my ears for once ).

I like Elliot's also (Mostly because I love the song).

And Paris sounded good.

Not my best for Taylor though.

Lisa and Mandisa didn't do that great IMHO.

Kelly's was ok, it was cute.

Katherine didn't really stand out that much.

Bucky, eh ok.

I think Lisa should be kicked off this time.....

I missed lil' chicken man

[rosethecopycat]

I want to let you know that my husband, Chris is playing solo piano for Kevin Kovias on a taping of the Ellen DeGeneres show filmed here in Orlando at Universal Studios.

It probably will air this coming Tuesday.

My husband will have a private, catered dressing room.
That's a big step up from having to change clothes in the restrooms, which we frequently have to do.

(Please ignore all those things I said about Kevin- they are not true anymore )

[joanofark]

I want to let you know that my husband, Chris is playing solo piano for Kevin Kovias on a taping of the Ellen DeGeneres show filmed here in Orlando at Universal Studios.

It probably will air this coming Tuesday.

My husband will have a private, catered dressing room.
That's a big step up from having to change clothes in the restrooms, which we frequently have to do.

(Please ignore all those things I said about Kevin- they are not true anymore )

Ohhhhhhhhhhhh COOL! Congrats to you and your husband!! So did you get to meet him??

[rosethecopycat]

My husband said the show taping went smoothly, and Kevin was easy to follow and that he was nice.

More details later, I haven't seen my husband since Friday night.

[Felix]

The performances I enjoyed tonight were...of course Chris I LOVE you Chris ,Elliot,and although im not pickles biggest fan I think she done ok tonight.The rest were kinda boring for me.