School bans students from talking

[crow_noir]

http://abcnews.go.com/2020/

The guy with the mustache.

http://abcnews.go.com/2020/Stossel/

Who's John S.?

[Alysser]

That's a bit much. I mean, at my old school we weren't allowed to talk much in class and stuff, but lunch? That's a time for talking! I'd have to kill myself. Lucky I don't go to that school. I'd want to transfer.

[JenBKR]

Maybe they should just liquidize all the food in the school. Problem solved.

But then they might choke if they drink it too fast! I think each child should be assigned a nurse to feed them through an IV. And of course, we need to get rid of recess, I mean, someone could fall and get hurt. Maybe each child should have a little bubble to live in at all times, so if they do fall or anything it won't hurt.

[Hellow]

Oh yeah, and we would have to saw off every rough edge or corner in the world, lay bubble wrap on the ground and the walls, and make them wear sun glasses when they are using a computer or watching tv. I mean banning talking during LUNCH. I mean, DUDE! Thats a little bit obsessive, even if only for a short time, what good will it do?

[lunasmom]

That is craziness. I'm sorry, but kids who grow up suffocated by rules and not being allowed to just be kids and have fun grow up with a lot of issues. Safety is good, but not at the cost of their social/mental health.

I'm probably just sensitive because I felt strangled by the ridiculous rules in my high school, but I really think kids should be allowed to play and talk and be kids... That's why you have teachers watching, they took care of the choking incidents, everything was okay. No need for such extreme measures.

[dogzr#1]

I'd probably die from not being able to talk at lunch rather than dying from choking on it.

Seriously though, I think it is a bit extreme to ban talking because two kids choked on food. It may not have even been the talking to blame, they could've been eating too fast as I know that has happened to me before.

I think this may cause more problems than solutions. A trouble kid or two may want to rebel against this strict rule and talk a lot or even start a food fight of some sort. I know when I was in elementary school, we had to be quiet in the cafeteria if we wanted to have recess. A paraprofessional would stand there watching us eat and if we got too loud, she'd blow a whistle. If she had to blow it more than 3 times, we wouldn't have recess. It was tough not to talk and most of the time we didn't have recess because it was SO tempting to talk while we were eating. It's like our nature or something!

Yes, it was sad that these kids choked on the food, but I don't think shutting them up completely will be the answer! Like CatLady said (sorry, I don't know your name) the kids should learn that if you talk too much and eat to fast, that it could lead to choking.