Memory Card Reader help

[shais_mom]

I have 2 different brands of cameras now. One is a Nikon and the other is Canon. I have contemplating on getting a memory card reader. They both take the same kind of card. My computer is an older model and doesn't have it on the front of it like some of the newer ones.
I have heard that it u/l pics faster. And I've heard there is no difference.
Anyone have one? Use one?
thoughts?

[BitsyNaceyDog]

We never use our card reader any more. The only thing we ever used it for was to upload videos off the camera. Our old computer wouldn't upload videos straight from the camera.

Both our card reader and camera use USB and I think they both upload at about the same speed. If you're looking for something a little faster you may want to look for a card reader that uses firewire rather than USB.

[shais_mom]

that uses firewire rather than USB.

a what??!?!
seriously
I really have no idea what a firewire is!

[shais_mom]

well I don't think I can edit the poll. I knew I was forgetting something!
I really don't think that uploading from my camera - canon is all that slow. I just am trying to get away the fact that I have to keep plugging each in USB cord.

My new Nikon is 7.1 MP - and I "THINK" I have it on the highest setting. I've checked the book and it says that the mode I have it on is reccommended for high quality prints with the one gig card I'll get like 3000 pics! that just doesn't sound right to me. But that is what it says! B/c with my Canon I "only" got 300 on the S2 @ highest MP. I uploaded about 60 pics the other nite from my canon and u/l it to the computer took about 2-3 minutes. Uploading those 60 images to imagestation took like 45 minutes.
I plugged in the Nikon @ the highest setting - 120 pics were u/l to my computer took no kidding less than 2 minutes. Uploading them to imagestation took less than 10 min. Which is what makes me think that I have it on the wrong setting but they LOOK fine.

http://www.imagestation.com/album/pi...il-AlbumInvite

[Blue_Frog]

I would get a card reader for a couple reasons --

1. you dont have to keep go behind the computer to switch between cables. I dont think the Nikon and Canon have the same sized ports, but I could be wrong

2. prevents the bending of the pins plugging in the cable at the camera end -- my mom did this to hers, so now has no other option than to use the card reader i bought her.

3. Doesn't cause a drain on your cameras battery. Not a huge deal i know, but nothing sucks more than downloading like a thousand pics, and having the battery die.


Best Buy has one for about $20 -- but i'm sure you could find one for around the same price at any electronics dealer

[shais_mom]

thanks!
Our Walmart didn't have what I was looking for so that's probably where I'll head this weekend.

[Jessika]

well I don't think I can edit the poll. I knew I was forgetting something!
I really don't think that uploading from my camera - canon is all that slow. I just am trying to get away the fact that I have to keep plugging each in USB cord.

I use the USB cord to upload images from my camera to my computer. I used to use a card reader, but it was ssllllooowwwww. Uploading from the cameras is SO much faster than the card reader. I have Canons, too, and they are not slow at all uploading to the comp

And the only plugging in you would have to do, if you left a USB cord plugged in the whole time, is plug it into your camera. You would already have to do this even if you bought a card reader, keep the card reader (which would be USB hopefully) plugged in at all times and take the card out of the camera and plug it into the card reader. More steps, IMO. Most newer cameras use just a regular USB cord to connect to the computer, so you SHOULDN'T have to swap out camera cords each time. If you do, then maybe a card reader would be a better choice. But if you don't, and the cords are universal, I would suggest just sticking to using the camera to upload pics.

Anyway if there IS a speed difference, you would have to buy a more expensive card reader to notice it, and even then it just wouldn't be worth the money IMO.

[shais_mom]

well I do have to switch the cords when I upload them b/c they are different ends. - which is understandable since they are two different kinds of cameras. But even when I had 2 fuji's I had to keep them both plugged in at all times b/c they were different. But my sister's old Canon and my new Canon fit the same cord. Go figure!!
Thanks for all the replies - I'm finding it interesting in hearing what everyone uses.

[catnapper]

Do you have an "other" option?

I think its a matter of how quickly your older computer can process theinfo. Its only faster on the new model computers because they can process everything that much faster.


Downloading with my Nikon took forever using the USB. Downloading with my Canon's USB is lightening fast. Its so fast on the Canon that the card reader thingie is actually a lot slower because its attached to my computer and takes a few seconds to wake up from its sleep The card reader WAS faster with my Nikon. I think its all a matter of your computer speed, and the speed in which your camera downloads.