How do you pronounce it?

[Chilli]

I think both are correct. I use both but in different situations. Like when refering to Pirates of the Caribbean, I say Care-a-bee-an. But talking about a caribbean cruise or something, i say the second one, Ka-rib-e-an. Hope that made sense!

Exactly how I say it.

[Almita]

I pronounce it the first way.

[jackie]

both, but usually the second way!

[Danegirl2208]

Care-a-bee-an..i cant get myself to say it the other way