Oh, good! I voted for #2. Plus it is easily hidden by wearing your hair down when doing those vicarage visits.

As for those who recommended eyebrows - I know a girl who had it done, and then regretted it, because when she decided to stop wearing an earring there, she said it just looked like a permanent zit. NOT a look she was going for!

Keep it clean - be scrupulous about it, and watch it carefully for infection, as there's less "flesh" there, and an infection can get very painful very quickly. (A long time ago I worked at an Earring Tree and pierced other people's ears, and that's what the manager told me to tell anyone who got pierced above the "fleshy" part of the lobe.)