Matching tragus was what I originally thought, too. My piercer, however, says that my tragus on the right is really too small to pierce. He said I would risk rejection and migration, plus it would stick straight out from the side of my head!

Thanks, everyone, for your input. I think I've decided on pic #2 (with your help... thanks!) and no, I won't be GETTING a billion more... I just WANT them! I won't be eligible for Ripley's any time soon!.