Thanks carrie. I'll try that! When I let her in she thinks she's gonna get it no matter what. She'll run over to it, and look at me, then look up at where it is. I usually just pretend its not there and ignore it/her if she was bad. But I tell her how good she is and get all excited when she comes in good. She flips out, so excited and stuff. SHe just LOVES the rope, its not funny, its her precious little toy