I missed this thread, but found it and decided to answer anyway! Tito and Sophie are lucky if they get one treat each, two to four times a week. (Unless someone goes to the vet or gets stepped on and Meowmie feels guilty.) Usually a small treat too - a Temptation (Tito's favorite) or a Pit'r Pat (Sophie's favorite). I have never fed them table scraps. AND they only get 1/2 cup of food each a day. AND Tito's on diet food.

And they are both still pudgy WHY??

Do cats store food, like a bear getting ready to go into hibernation?