Thanks

I don't think my grandfather would listen , I guess Im just going to bring a toy upstairs everytime I bring Jasper up to see him.

My grandpa really likes Jasper, and if Im busy one day, and don't bring Jasper up, if I go up to get something or to tell them something, he will say "How is Jasper? I haven't seem him yet today!!" That's my hint

Also I don't think the apple spray will work, vinegar doesn't even work , he eats everything LOL