Kelly your response was totally appropriate. This person needed to be "woken up" to what cats are all about. As much as my hubby and myself adore our kitties, he has always said "innately these little fellows are hunter/killers." It doesn't sound so nice to think of them that way, but that's how they were "wired" by their Creator. It's part of the "kitty package." This person was very irresponsible to have not kept a better watch on her pets that were not "kitty compatible."