It's the same thing for me. I went into user cp and changed the default to "no", went to the bottom of the page and had it save the changes but I still get emails! I have never before gotten so many emails It's nice to get an email and all, but it's getting a bit out of control

Even when I have closed out of PT and gone back in the next day, in my user cp it's still showing "no" to getting emails, but still I get emails.