Thank you all for the replies. The way some of you explain it is exactly how her behavior is. She does this only on instinct! I will get her away from this treat and she will be back to being the best dog. I have played the game of giving it to her and taking it and no problem while doing this. However it happens when she is into the treat for a while and I will walk up on her and bang the instinct takes over. But again the time I take the treat it stops and she is fine with me having the treat. I will try the crate for time out.
I do have a question for that though. She is never in her crate and really never has been. I used it when she was young, but she hated it in there. When she does something wrong (jumps on the furniture) do I just take her to the basement where the crate is and put her in it? How many minutes? Should the crate be located somewhere different?
Thanks

[ December 02, 2001: Message edited by: Iluvbrits ]