I think it's generally a great diet! I've heard more good stories than bad. It really depends on the dog though.

My dogs used to be on the raw diet. I switched them back to kibble because of the cost and lack of room. We're getting an upright freezer soon so I'll be putting them back on raw since we can buy in bulk. They did really well on it, especially Kaedyn. I just realized recently how horrible their teeth are, how much bigger their poops are, Kaedyn's lower energy level, their okay-ish coats and how much itchier they seem to be since switching back to kibble.